MANCHESTER RESTAURANT REVIEWS - The French by Simon Rogan Manchester |About Us |Contact Us|Advertise
Restaurants Of Manchester  
click here for Manchester Hotels

The French by Simon Rogan
CLICK HERE TO BOOK ONLINE or Tel. 0871 230 5347
Midland Hotel, Peter Street, Manchester, M60 2DS [map]
Historic restaurant at The Midland Hotel, the first in the UK to receive a Michelin Star back in 1974, now operated by 2 Star L'Enclume chef Simon Rogan since February 2013
*=Calls to 0871 numbers cost up to 10p per minute from BT landlines. Other networks and mobiles will vary
  ~ Advertisement ~

Michael Caines Restaurant Manchester
Australasia Manchester
63 Degrees Manchester
Aubaine Manchester
Room Restaurant Manchester
Second Floor Restaurant at Harvey Nichols Manchester
Linen Restaurant Manchester
City Cafe Manchester
Vermilion Restaurant Manchester
Opus One Manchester
Podium Restaurant at the Hilton Manchester
Alto Manchester
Kaleido Restaurant Manchester
Damson MediaCityUK
Don Giovannis Manchester
Fahrenheit Manchester
Livebait Restaurant Manchester
24 Bar & Grill Manchester
Annies Manchester
Avalanche Manchester
The Botanist - Alderley Edge
47 King Street West Manchester
 
 
The French by Simon Rogan Manchester ~ overall reviews
food
price
service
smartness
overall:
most popular dish: 10 Course Menu (£79)

Simon Rogan at The French Manchester ~ our review
Is Manchester Ready For The Finest Of Fine Dining? (May 2013)
Trusted Reviewer "For many a year, our great city has proved itself to be superb at delivering fun, cool, funky, casual dining. Fine dining however is something which we've never been able to crack properly. In past efforts, the food has been great, but the service casually lacking. The chef's name on the door impressive, but the reality falling sadly short. The Champagne list great, but the food average. The decor amazing, but the experience pretentious. There's always been something to put a major spanner in the works. To be blunt, there just hasn’t been a big enough market for it in the region, which therefore creates reliance on out-of-town customers. However, despite the fact that foodies don’t mind travelling for a meal, Manchester isn’t a place which the rest of the nation mentions in the same breath as fine food.

We've slept in a tent before now, just to be able to eat some of the best food in the country, due to a lack of available hotel rooms at the time. It’s a sacrifice that you happily, in fact excitedly make, for doing something which you love. Sky high Manchester rents, along with a large reliance on booze revenue, are also factors in deterring independent, top quality fine-dining eateries from opening in Manchester city centre - 63 Degrees in the Northern Quarter being a notable exception.

Due to this, the cycle of booze friendly eating is predominant, as places soon realise that you can make more money by selling booze to the masses. Cool concepts such as burgers, late lounges, and BBQ joints are the current go-to places in Manchester, with a new one seemingly sprouting up every other week. So, how does a fine dining restaurant sustain itself in Manchester city centre, outlasting the passing fashions and trends? Is Manchester ready for true top end fine dining, and can it be sustained, where everywhere else has failed to date?

The French - new look

True, Michael Caines at ABode and Australasia are still fully booked most nights despite being open a few years now but they're both affordable, inclusive establishments with no aspirations for a Michelin Star, something which reportedly irked talented master chefs Ian Matfin and Paul Greening respectively, with each walking out, the later no sooner than he had started.

In early 2013, multi-award winning super-chef, at Cumbria's dual Michelin starred L'Enclume; Simon Rogan, declared his opinion that we are indeed more than ready, and so became The French in its current guise. As many of Manchester diners are already aware, The French has been a gem in Manchester's food crown for a generation. It was a legendary room, which back in 1974 won a Michelin Star; the last time which our city centre has gained one in fact and failed to hold for over 30 years since. The appeal of The French, its character, its charm, and indeed its very ethos, ironically were also what eventually became its problem. We loved it, but it was old fashioned, "Voila!" silver service, and needed some fresh blood to appeal to a new generation of customers. When the time came for The Midland, Manchester's grandest hotel, to revamp, they turned to Chef Rogan. Outside of food circles, Simon Rogan is perhaps an unknown in fairness. Within food circles however, he's mentioned in the same breath as household names such Blumenthal, White, and Ramsay, as well as other perhaps slightly lesser known culinary heavyweights such as Howard, Bains, Clifford, Caines, Outlaw, Wareing, Atherton, etc. In short, Manchester was about to be graced with an eatery, driven by one of the most talented UK chefs of our time. This was a big deal. A very big deal.

Following in the footsteps of Steve Coogan and Rob Brydon in The Trip, we dined at L'Enclume earlier this year, ahead of the big opening. We were lucky enough to sit down with Chef Rogan, and also The French's new Head Chef, Adam Reid, to find out what they had in store for The French. We were told that the food would be 'The same as L'Enclume'. High expectations were set ahead of our arrival due to this statement. We anticipated no half measures, no watered down Manchester experience. We were excited.

The décor for us, whilst being bright, airy, and admittedly well turned out, isn’t our cup of tea in all honesty. It’s a strange hybrid of old and new, which for us never truly gels. The French of old was a special room, a massive part of the old restaurant itself and an important part of the Midland Hotel's rich history. In short, it was a legendary space, and without doubt one of our favourite dining rooms anywhere in the world.

The French - new look

The new décor is challenging to say the least. The wood effect carpet in particular being more than... erm... 'interesting'. We spent the first 10 minutes into our meal scrutinising the décor and mourning our loss, but after that you really don’t notice, and why would you? A great interior alone doesn't keep customers coming back, something which Manchester knows all too well and yet never seems to learn from.

Here though, you're eating some of the most accomplished food in the country. That’s the thing with any top end dining experience. The décor, in short, just doesn’t matter after the initial impression is made on you. That’s exactly how it should be. You should walk away thinking about your meal, not the wallpaper.

The décor, in any restaurant is purely functional, and to large degree, peripheral. If we can live with the new décor, based on our history and affinity with its predecessor, then anybody can. Then again, with hindsight, having written about it here at so much length, maybe we're still trying to convince ourself.

The menu is tasting format; for us, the only way to eat in a fine dining restaurant. Three (£29), six (£55) or ten courses (£79) being the advertised options, but with the addition of a few extras, the final number of our ten course menu was 15 dishes. Dinner here isn’t just a meal, it's a whole evening, and an experience to boot. Never in a Manchester eatery have we encountered so many back-to-back courses which were so consistently excellent. Simon Rogan's claims of the food being 'The same as L'Enclume', were indeed very close to the mark. Regularly were the dishes excellent, on occasion awe inspiring, and only in a couple of cases, average in feel. Average is of course relevant to the whole meal, not to the Manchester market in general.

The food is very light, with just enough of a protein hit to remind you that you're eating meat/fish, all with a very fresh, natural feel, as is Rogan's style. Due to this, the matched wines were in every case bar one, white, and were exceptional in quality and pairing accuracy, across the board, not to mention being exceptionally varied in style as to avoid tedium. We are generally red wine lovers, so the superb, oaked, smoky Rioja which accompanied a guinea hen dish, was a welcome treat. The pulled pork amuse was outstanding, as were the mussels, in lookalike, edible shells. Sure, as with any tasting menu with so many courses, even barring technical faults, you'll find things on it which you're not too keen on, or prefer some courses a bit less than others.

Apart from a minor over seasoning on the still impressive ox with coal oil, and the slightly dubious texture of the sole, 95% of the meal was pure excellence, executed with precision, with some real twists of genius. Some dishes please you, some amaze you, but none could be faulted to any great technical degree. When you're eating three courses, that’s always pleasing. When you're eating 15 courses, that is some achievement.

 

The French menu

The man at the helm, Chef Adam Reid, a Manchester lad himself, should be amazingly proud at what has been done at The French. Not only is his kitchen producing food which is on the same level as L'Enclume, but his front of house staff are outstanding. Forget snooty, serious service, which Mancunians run a mile from. This is top end, yet still slick, friendly, efficient work, with immaculate attention to detail, without a grain of pretence or arrogance. Only one restaurant other than The French which we've ever dined at, anywhere in the world, at any level, has ever noticed my dining companion being left handed, and suitably set every subsequent course's cutlery in the appropriate way. You'd think that more places would notice this really, but it's sadly never the case, despite 10% of the population having this preference. Even L'Enclume themselves didn’t pick up on this. Impressively, the gentleman who looked after us for most of the evening had, before working at The French, been with a high street chain restaurant. There was no suggestion of this whatsoever, which is a testament to the training and standards which the front of house staff, headed up by the ever charming Rebecca and Kamilla, adhere to. The whole food, drink, and service package stacks up to an almost flawless offering.

Also, it's very good value. £79 each may sound a lot for dinner, with £60 for the matched wine flight topping the whole mean up to about £140 per person, with a little extra for cheese, Port, and coffee etc. But then they don’t add the annoying compulsory/covert 12.5% 'service charge' which even some casual chains now slap onto your bill.

Should you opt not to go for the matched wine flight, then there is an elaborate wine list, featuring a lot of accessible bottles, as well as some real vineyard heavyweights. You get 15 courses for your money, with around nine small glasses of very nice wine via the matched flight. A shade over £5 a course, or £7 per high quality small glass of wine. Sure, they are small, starter sized portions/glasses, but how much do you pay for a starter in a high street chain.

People will travel from London to dine in The French, in fact they are doing so already, in droves. Last year, London foodies hated being told 'The best restaurant in the country is now in Cumbria, 275 miles away'. It hurt them badly, and it shocked Michelin too. And now, Manchester city centre has a star in its midst, one which people are travelling to experience. That’s the biggest compliment that anybody could pay to a restaurant in Manchester. Their visit to the city, as well as their dining experience, are all wrapped up within a majestic hotel, where Rolls met Royce and where they can spend the night too, and break a few old fashioned Northern myths.

The French is no longer The French, it's something else, it’s something better. It's the biggest deal for the Manchester food scene in a generation, it's a great coup for the city's tourism in general, and is without question the best restaurant in the North of England, barring L'Enclume itself. There is no shame in the latter though, since L'Enclume is arguably the best restaurant in the country at the moment. Welcome to Manchester Simon Rogan. We are absolutely ready! ~ restaurants of manchester 26/6/13 (visited on a Saturday evening)

food
price
service
smartness
overall
"flawless"
"bang for buck"
"impeccable"
"not our cup of tea"
"Michelin standard"


The French at The Midland ~ members' reviews
"I'm a big fan of Simon Rogan having been to L'Enclume in Cartmel a couple of times. The tastes he extracts from the foods he prepares are amazing. He has a gift for producing food with flavours that are outstanding and The French was no different, the food was excellent. Simon, was actually cooking that evening - it is always good to see a big name chef still in the kitchen and cooking. I was invited into the kitchen and talked to him for a good 5 minutes. On the down side, whilst I understand Simon is not one to look for publicity, I thought after service it would have been to the restaurant's advantage if he had stepped out into the public area. The restaurant, which, with the exception of the lighting, is simply but nicely and effictively decorated, offers 5 star food and service so expect the prices to match - although this is still very good value for the service you receive. They staff spent plenty of time to explain each dish and answer any questions. The whole experience is everything that you would expect from a chef of this standard, who I believe is the best, having dined at several celebrity chefs' restaurants. 5 stars! " - ian hill, manchester - NEW MEMBER (26/6/13 visited on a thursday evening)

"The French is very nice and the food was very impressive but a visit once in six months is enough. It will never replace the 'old' French for ambience and class and there's not much choice in New World wines" - joe whittle, stockport - NEW MEMBER (3/4/13 visited on a friday evening)

"I do not like placing negative restaurant reviews but feel that to get to a French restaurant that has been so completely changed and have no menu choice is very wrong and deceiving. Having enjoyed the Midland French for over 25 years, it has always been our special restaurant. I love French cuisine and the restaurant never failed to please us. The new modern glass ball light fittings are stunning, however for a romantic dinner it was terrible, the lights are too bright and the wooden tables, with no cloths, no side plates and all the cutlery placed to the right gives it too much of a bistro style. Babies are also now allowed in to the restaurant. I love children but, having paid a babysitter to enjoy a romantic dinner out, I feel it is wrong to have other people's inflicted on you. The decor is bland and they have destroyed any nod to The French. The name should be changed straight away.

The new menu is strange. No a la carte menu, just a choice of a six or ten course tasting dishes only. each a real mix of foods and ideas. We were informed that they may add some a la carte dishes eventually but the Cartmel customers did not want this. It's not French at all. If you expect to pay for an a la carte meal (as before) just don't compare as this is not a meal, just bits of tasters. The service is also completely different to how it was before. Inundated with bits of food on horrid scratchy plates and bowls, mixed and mashed dishes and no real meal. The staff were constantly asking us for feedback, interrupting and questioning then pulling sour faces if we did not like the item. There was too many dishes to describe all but one memorable course was one mussel each in an edible charcoal shell served cold on a platter of black pebbles. Another course had two weird fried balls (one tiny one each) of dock and nettle leaves, seemingly a traditional Northern dish known as Doc Pudding?. All the dishes came with sprigs and sprouts and bits of pickle and the odd crunch and puffed linseed. The best bit was the Sarsassparilla drink (all one centimetre of it) served in a pot beaker at the end. By which time I was glad to escape. I won't go again." - heather taylor, oldham - NEW MEMBER (29/3/13 visited on a wednesday evening)



Submit a Review of Simon Rogan at The French Manchester
To submit a review of The French Restaurant Manchester, you must be a Pride Of Manchester member...
Not yet a Member?
Pride Of Manchester members receive weekly...
~ Exclusive restaurant offers (including 2 for 1 deals)
~ Exclusive theatre offers (including many 2 for 1 deals)
~ Exclusive bar offers (including many 2 for 1 deals)
~ The latest news of what's on in Manchester (new concerts to be announced, comedy shows, cinema releases and pre-sale info)
We promise never to share your info with anyone else and you can manage your subscription at any point.
 
Already a Member?
If you're already a Pride Of Manchester member, simply enter your details below to submit your review...
Only members can post reviews...
Your full name:
Email address:
[back to top]
our hotel websites
manchester
our theatre guides
 
   
Disclaimer: All information correct 1/4/2011. RestaurantsOfManchester.com and ManchesterRestaurants.com can not be held responsible for any differences experienced at the premises listed. All images and information © 2002-13 PrideOfManchester